Empathy: The Key to Successful Client Intake
When a prospective client calls your law firm, your intake person usually has a very specific job to do: get the caller’s name, find out what happened, determine whether the matter fits the firm’s practice areas, gather enough information to evaluate the lead, and schedule a consultation if appropriate. All of that matters, but there’s another part of the intake process that can be just as important and is often overlooked.
Before your intake person starts collecting facts, they should take a moment to respond to the person behind those facts. In other words, they need to show empathy.
Your Intake Script Shouldn’t Sound Like an Intake Script
Most intake people are friendly, polite, and professional. They know the questions they’re supposed to ask, and they understand the information the firm needs to collect. The problem is that the conversation can still come across as transactional if the intake person moves too quickly from the caller’s problem to the next question on the script.
A caller says they were injured in a car accident, and the intake person immediately asks, “What date did the accident happen?”
A homeowner says their house is scheduled for a sheriff’s sale, and the next question is, “How much do you owe on the mortgage?”
Someone calls after losing a parent, and the intake person moves directly into questions about whether there’s a will.
Those questions may all be necessary, but when they come too quickly, the caller may feel like they’re talking to a form instead of a person.
A much better first response is often something simple and human.
If someone calls a personal injury firm after a car accident, the intake person might say, “Oh, I’m so sorry. Were you seriously injured?” That one sentence accomplishes two things at the same time. It shows genuine concern for what the caller has been through, while also getting information the firm needs to know about the seriousness of the potential case.
That’s what good intake should do: gather useful information without losing sight of the fact that there’s a real person on the other end of the phone.
Respond to the Human Problem First
The same principle applies across practice areas.
If someone calls a bankruptcy firm because they’re facing an imminent foreclosure sale, the intake person might say, “Oh, I’m so sorry you’re dealing with that. That must be very stressful. Hopefully we’ll be able to help you save your home.”
If someone contacts an estate administration attorney after the death of a loved one, a natural response might be, “Oh, I’m so sorry for your loss. This must be a very difficult time for you.”
None of these responses is complicated, and none require expensive technology, a new CRM, or a completely rewritten intake process. They simply require your intake team to listen to what the caller is saying and acknowledge the emotional reality of the situation before moving on to the next question.
That small change can make a big difference because the caller isn’t just evaluating whether your firm is competent. They’re also deciding how your firm feels. Will you listen to them? Will you understand what they’re going through? Will you treat them like a person or just another file? Will you take care of them?
Those impressions start forming long before the prospective client ever speaks with the attorney, and in many firms they begin with the first person who answers the phone. That means your intake team isn’t simply gathering information; they’re shaping the prospective client’s first emotional experience with your firm.
People Remember How You Made Them Feel
Prospective clients often speak with more than one attorney before deciding whom to hire, and from their perspective, the firms may begin to sound very similar. Everyone says they’re experienced. Everyone says they care about their clients. Everyone has testimonials, case results, and professional-looking websites. What may stand out far more is the firm where someone immediately responded with warmth, concern, and understanding.
People tend to make decisions emotionally and then use logic to justify those decisions. That’s especially true when the service being purchased is difficult to evaluate in advance, as legal services often are. A prospective client may not be in a position to determine which lawyer is technically the best lawyer for the matter, but they can determine very quickly how your firm makes them feel.
If the first interaction creates trust, comfort, and rapport, the caller may already feel a connection to your firm before the intake process is finished. And when the legal credentials of competing firms appear roughly comparable, that emotional connection can become a meaningful competitive advantage.
Empathy Has to Be Genuine
There is one important caution: you don’t want to turn empathy into just another mechanical line on the intake script. If every intake person simply reads, “I’m sorry to hear that,” in the same flat tone before moving to question number four, you haven’t accomplished much.
The goal is to teach your team to recognize what the caller is experiencing and respond naturally. That may require some training and role-playing so your staff becomes comfortable pausing, listening, and responding in a way that feels sincere rather than scripted.
You can practice different types of calls with your intake team and talk through the emotions the caller may be experiencing in each situation. Encourage your staff to slow down for a moment instead of racing through the checklist. The exact words matter less than the intent behind them. What matters is that the prospective client feels heard and understood before the conversation moves into the more businesslike part of the intake process.
Great Client Service Starts Before Someone Becomes a Client
Law firms spend a lot of time thinking about how to provide excellent service after a client hires them, but the client experience begins much earlier. It starts with the first phone call, the first email, or the first conversation with someone on your team. A few seconds of genuine empathy can change the entire tone of that interaction and send a powerful message about the kind of firm you run.
Your intake person can still gather all the information your firm needs, follow the script, and qualify the lead efficiently. The difference is that they can do it while making the caller feel heard, understood, and cared for. And sometimes, that small difference is exactly what causes a prospective client to choose your firm instead of the one they call next.
Want More?
Was this helpful? Intriguing? Thought provoking? Well, there’s more where that came from! You can get great business and professional practice tips in your inbox every week by subscribing to my newsletter! You’ll get actionable, bite-sized tips every Friday to help you make more money by spending less time and providing better legal services!
Related Topics
If you liked this information and found it useful, then you might like or need these others:
Take Back Your Practice
If you want to make more money in less time and be home for dinner every night, then you need this book!
